ExpressHomeSale
Street view of 387 S Shore Dr, Sarasota, FL 34234, USA

387 S Shore Dr, Sarasota, FL 34234, USA

Estimated Market Value

$0
Range: $5,791,020 - $6,798,153
Zillow Zestimate®: $5,813,300
Powered by Zillow

Valuation Comparison

Our Estimate
$6,294,587
Range: $5,791,020 - $6,798,153
Zillow Zestimate®View on Zillow
$5,813,300
Range: $4,941,305 - $6,801,561
30-Day Trend
+$262,233(4.7%)

Zestimate® is a registered trademark of Zillow, Inc. Valuation models differ based on data availability, proprietary algorithms, and recent market shifts.

3Beds
3Baths
5,636SqFt
2022Built
2Garage

AI Property Analysis

This stunning 2022-built residence at 387 S Shore Drive offers an unparalleled luxury living experience in Sarasota, Florida. Spanning an impressive 5,636 square feet of living space across two stories, this home features 3 spacious bedrooms and 3.5 elegant bathrooms within its 8 thoughtfully designed rooms. The quality of construction is evident with its masonry structure, stucco exterior, gypsum board interiors, and durable ceramic flooring, all built on a secure piling foundation, ensuring both beauty and resilience. Designed for the discerning homeowner, this property truly embraces the coveted Florida waterfront lifestyle. It boasts direct canal access complete with a private boat dock/ramp and a sturdy bulkhead/sea wall, perfect for boating enthusiasts. Outdoor entertaining is a dream with a sparkling pool, an expansive patio, and inviting open porches. Inside, comfort and sophistication are enhanced by modern air conditioning, efficient heating, two cozy fireplaces, and an attached two-car garage, providing ample space and convenience. Situated on a generous 0.517-acre lot within the desirable Sapphire Shores subdivision, this home offers both privacy and prime access to Sarasota's famed aquatic offerings. Its relatively new construction means contemporary design, systems, and finishes are already in place, presenting a turn-key opportunity for those seeking a luxurious, low-maintenance haven. This residence represents an exceptional opportunity to own a meticulously crafted, amenity-rich waterfront property in one of Florida's most sought-after coastal communities.

Capital Gains Tax Analysis

Section 121 Primary Residence Exemption Analysis

Total Potential Taxable Gain
$0
Based on estimated value of $6,294,587 minus purchase price of $6,350,000
Based on public records, this property has been owned for approximately 3.6 years. A homeowner may qualify for the Section 121 exclusion if all IRS requirements — including ownership, use as a primary residence, and timing — are satisfied. Public property records alone cannot determine individual eligibility. Consult a qualified tax professional.

Single Filer

Up to $250K Exclusion

Protected Amount:$0
Capital Gains Rate:20%
Potential Tax Savings:$0

Married Filing Jointly

Up to $500K Exclusion

Protected Amount:$0
Capital Gains Rate:20%
Potential Tax Savings:$0

Tax Liability Comparison

* This analysis is a simplified illustration based on an assumed 20% federal capital gains tax rate. It does not account for state taxes, depreciation recapture, the Net Investment Income Tax (3.8%), AMT, or individual circumstances. The Section 121 exclusion has specific IRS requirements regarding ownership, use, and timing that cannot be determined from public property records alone. This platform is not acting as a tax adviser, accountant, or attorney. Consult a licensed CPA or tax attorney to evaluate your specific situation. Calculation date: August 2026.

Financial Projections

Estimated Net Proceeds

Estimated Cash in Hand:$762,999

These projections assume a 5.5% total sales commission, approximately 6% in closing costs and concessions, and mortgage payoff estimated from public purchase records (30-year fixed, 20% down payment, 5% assumed interest rate). Actual proceeds will vary based on negotiated terms, local costs, and current mortgage balance. This is not an appraisal or guaranteed estimate of net proceeds.

Equity Breakdown

Cost to Build Today$1,296,280
Investor Quick-Sale Est.$4,169,534
Monthly Rental Est.$25,178/mo
📊 Assumptions Used in This Analysis: Home appreciation rate: 3.5% (long-term U.S. historical average) • S&P 500 return: 10% (historical average, not guaranteed) • High-yield savings: 5% (current estimate, subject to change) • Bonds/CDs: 4% (current estimate) • Insurance: 0.4% of home value annually • Maintenance: 1% of home value annually • Opportunity cost: 5% annually • Mortgage balance: estimated from public purchase records assuming 30-year fixed, 20% down, 5% interest rate • Property taxes are NOT included • All projections are hypothetical illustrations and do not guarantee future results. Past performance is not indicative of future returns.

Your Appreciation Story

Your Annual Return-0.2%Compound growth rate
Historical Average3.5%Long-term US average
Above-Average Growth+$0Growth above historical 3.5% baseline

Your home has appreciated at -0.2% per year — below the historical average of 3.5%. This extraordinary growth was driven by recent market conditions that are unlikely to repeat. Understanding this context is key to making smart decisions about your equity. Past performance does not guarantee future results.


What Could Your Equity Do?

If you sold today and invested your $762,999 equity in the S&P 500, in 10 years it could grow to $1,979,023 — compared to an estimated $4,071,426 in total equity by staying in the home. These projections are hypothetical. Investment returns are not guaranteed and involve risk of loss.


The Hidden Cost of Holding

Insurance (0.4% est)$2,098/mo
Maintenance (1% est)$5,245/mo
Opportunity Cost (5% est)$3,179/mo
Total Monthly Holding Cost$10,523/mo

* Estimates do not include property taxes (county, city, school, or special district). Actual costs vary significantly by location and individual circumstances. This platform is not acting as a financial or investment adviser.

The estimated monthly cost of holding this property is approximately $10,523/month. This includes an estimated $3,179/month in opportunity cost — the hypothetical return that equity could earn if invested elsewhere. These figures are estimates and actual costs will vary.

Market Pulse

Market Temp
❄️ Cool

Slower price growth and extended listing times suggest a more buyer-friendly environment.

Your Neighborhood

Nestled in the picturesque Sapphire Shores subdivision, this address places you in the heart of Sarasota, a city celebrated for its vibrant arts, culture, and stunning Gulf Coast beaches. Residents here enjoy a sophisticated coastal lifestyle with easy access to exquisite dining, upscale shopping, and abundant recreational opportunities, all supported by the highly-rated Sarasota County School District. The current market conditions continue to highlight the enduring appeal of Sarasota's waterfront properties, solidifying homeowners' investments in this thriving and desirable community.

Market Trend Projections

1 Year Forecast$6,514,898Range: $6.3M - $6.5M
3 Year Forecast$6,978,921Range: $6.3M - $7M
5 Year Forecast$7,475,995Range: $6.3M - $7.5M

Estimated Monthly Equity Gain
+$18,359/mo

Based on moderate market appreciation projections, this property's estimated equity may increase by approximately this amount each month. Actual appreciation varies and is not guaranteed.

❄️Market Outlook & Sell Window

Buyer's market — consider waiting for conditions to improve

* These projections are hypothetical illustrations based on historical trends and local market data. Conservative: 0.0%, Moderate: 3.5%, Aggressive: 3.5%. Actual results will vary. Past performance does not guarantee future results. This platform is not acting as an appraiser or investment adviser. Projection date: August 2026.

⚖️ This analysis is for informational purposes only and does not constitute an appraisal, tax advice, legal advice, or investment advice. The platform and its operators are not acting as appraisers, accountants, attorneys, investment advisers, or tax advisers. Valuations shown are estimates based on publicly available data and automated models — they are not formal appraisals. Financial projections are illustrative and not guaranteed. Always consult with qualified professionals before making any real estate, financial, or tax decisions.
David Liberatore

Report Generated By

David Liberatore

Premier Sotheby's International Realty

Thinking Of Moving?

Let's have a conversation.